191 S ARABELLA Way, St. Johns, FL 32259 (MLS# 2141365)

Current Price: $700,000

Property Sub Type: Single Family Residence

Property Attached YN: No

Status: Active

List Price: $700,000

Listing Contract Date: 2026-04-22

Street Number: 191

Street Direction Prefix: S

Street Name: ARABELLA

Street Suffix: Way

County: St. Johns

State: FL

Postal Code: 32259

MLS Area Major: 301-Julington Creek/Switzerland

Subdivision Name: St Johns Forest

Bedrooms Total: 5

Bathrooms Full: 3

Bathrooms Half: 1

Bathrooms Total: 4

Living Area: 2602

Living Area Source: Public Records

Year Built: 2010

Accessory Dwelling Unit Y/N: No

Homestead YN: Yes

Lot Size Acres: 0.17

Association YN: Yes

Association Fee: 254

Association Fee Frequency: Monthly

CDD Fee YN: Yes

CDD Fee Amount: 487.72

Accessibility Features YN: No

New Construction YN: No

Garage YN: Yes

Garage Spaces: 2

Carport YN: No

Pool Private YN: Yes

Water Body Access YN: No

Waterfront YN: Yes

Stories: 2

Entry Level: 1

Senior Community YN: No

Directions: Turn onto St Johns Forest blvd from 210. Drive back towards Arabella, take a left, house on the right. Do NOT GO TO BACK GATE. Main entrance only where guard shack is located!

Public Remarks: Located in the prestigious St. Johns Forest, 191 Arabella Way is a move in ready, POOL home! St Johns Forest is a 24-hour man-gated community nestled within the A-rated St. Johns school district and is loaded with resort-style amenities, including a fitness center, tennis courts, and a massive pool with a tower slide. CDD BOND PAID OFF! Built by Taylor Morrison with concrete block construction, this home offers unmatched peace of mind. The property sits on a premier waterfront lot featuring resort-style, solar heated pool & spa with expansive views. The versatile floor plan boasts 4 bedrooms plus a massive bonus room w/full bathroom, a dedicated office, living room and a family room that flows into the kitchen. Major upgrades include a brand-new roof, newer HVAC, and fresh interior paint. From the custom closets throughout, crown moulding, and wood-look tile flooring - the quality craftsmanship shines in this amenity-rich and secure community. Experience the ultimate Florida lifestyle

List Price/SqFt: 269.02

Major Change Timestamp: 2026-04-22T18:56:52Z

Major Change Type: New Listing

DPR Eligible: Yes